Birth Order and Personality: Is there really a difference?
How often do you hear, “Oh, they’re both oldest children? Oh yeah… that’ll last.” Or, “She’s the baby of the family? She must be spoiled…” Do these things REALLY make a difference?
Why do people feel that birth order differences exist?
As Ziv & Hermel (2011) explained, as families tend to have more kids, the parental care is not evenly divided between all siblings. It is not that parents intentionally give more attention to one child than the other; it is just what ends up happening. When the first child is born, the child is often showered with attention and resources, and they do not have siblings to share these resources with. They are new to the family, they are exciting to their parents. They’re the first one! When the second child comes, the parents are then having to split all their resources between two children now instead of one. If the parents have no more children, the balance can be restored once the oldest child leaves the home. The second child then becomes, essentially, an “only child” because there is no one else at home to split their attention with. A lot of this is affected by the age difference between the two children. However, if the parents have a third child, the middle child never gets their alone time with the parents. The “baby” becomes an only child again when everyone else leaves the home. Ziv & Hermel go on to explain…
The competition between siblings for parental investment leads children to adopt family niches that are associated with birth order … As a result, middleborns prefer nonfamilial social interactions to familial ones, and they develop advanced social skills relative to firstborns and lastborns.
What some of the research says…
Sulloway (1996) thinks that the youngest children are often seen as rebels who want to change the world, while the oldest children are conscientious and support sticking with the “status quo”. MacDonald (1971) also states that the younger born children are more likely to believe that forces outside their control lead their behaviour while the older children are more likely to believe that they themselves (and not the external environment) control their behaviour. He also stated that the older children are more “socially responsible” and rigid compared their younger siblings.
Carette, Anseel & Van Yperen (2011) did find that first-born children are more likely to measure their success against themselves; adding that they often strive to meet goals in this same way. Eldest children tend to strive for an increase in knowledge, skill sets, and mastering tasks. Second-born children, however, are more likely to measure their successes against other people. They will strive mainly to prove how they are more competent than others… in essence, they want to be the “winners”.
Another study found that our personality traits tend to affect the type of parenting style we have. However, they also found that whether you are the oldest, middle, or baby in your family can play a role in the parenting you receive. Parents tend to use a authoritarian parenting style on middle and only children. Only children also tend to feel more pressure from their parents, as if they are their parents “only chance for success. Children of authoritarian parenting styles are also more likely to feel that their life as unfair and strict.
Lastly, Parents who feel that they have a sense of belonging and social interest are more likely to use an authoritative parenting style on their children than other parent’s personality traits (Gfroerer, Kern, Curlette, White & Jonyniené, 2011). And can you guess what sets of siblings see the highest rates of birth order differences? Well, according to Healey & Ellis (2007), it is sets of girls.
What the other Research says…
The problem with this topic, is that the research varies. Some research findings find results as stated above, while others find no statistical significance (Marini & Kurtz, 2011; Harthshorne, 2011). The problem is, in many of the research articles, it is hard to completely account for cultural, socio-economic, and parenting style differences. In addition, not all the studies measure personality in the same way. Some people swear by the research that there are personality differences based on birth order. Others swear that it’s a hyped up myth. It is sure clear that more concise research is needed to confidently rule in either direction.
While we may not be able to fully understand the effects of birth order, we do know one thing for sure. Each member of the family experiences family life and events differently from everyone else. Depending on the age of the child, they may not have the knowledge and capacity to fully understand certain situations. They may be the oldest and have more of an understanding of what’s happening in the family than the younger children. No matter what way you look at it, the view-point is skewed in some direction. It’s not good or bad, it’s just important to understand and know. If nothing else, the birth order is still a fun debate to have with another friend and read about.
What are your views of birth order? Do you think the placement in your family affected the way your personality turned out? Do you feel you were treated differently from your siblings?
Nicole Paulie is an author, Counselling Psychologist and co-founder of MyMoodandMe. She provides therapy in the Dublin city area. Contact us to learn more or to book an appointment.
Carette, B., Anseel, F., & Van Yperen, N. (2011). Born to learn or born to win? birth order effects on on achievement goals. Journal of Research in Personality, 45, 500-503.
Gfroerer, K., Kern, R., Curlette, W., White, J., & Jonyniené, J. (2011). Parenting style and personality: Perceptions of mothers, fathers, and adolescents. Journal of Individual Psychology,67(1), 57-73.
Hartshorne, J. K. (2011, January 11). How birth order affects your personality. Scientific American Mind, Retrieved fromhttp://www.scientificamerican.com/sciammind/?contents=2010-01
Healey, M. D., & Ellis, B. J. (2007). Birth order, conscientiousness, and openness to experience tests of the family-niche model of personality using a within-family methodology. Evolution and Human Behavior, 28, 55-59.
MacDonald, A. (1971). Birth order and personality. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 36(2), 171-176.
Marini, V. A., & Kurtz, J. E. (2011). Birth order differences in normal personality traits: Perspectives from within and outside the family. Personality and Individual Differences, 51, 910-914.
Sulloway, F. J. (1996). Born to rebel: Birth order, family dynamics, and creative lives. New York, NY: Pantheon Books.
Ziv, I., & Hermel, O. (2011). Birth order effects on the separation process in young adults: An evolutionary and dynamic approach. The American Journal of Psychology, 124(3), 261-273.